76
Alcohol in our lives
AcciDenTs AnD injury
While preventable deaths are one
important measure of alcohol harm,
the incidence of non-fatal alcohol-
related injuries in this country is of
even greater significance. Acute injury
is one of our most significant health
issues in relation to alcohol as each year
thousands of New Zealanders are injured
as a result of their own or somebody
elses drinking.
Injury accounts for over a third of
alcohols total contribution to the global
burden of disease and disability34 and,
because the young are overwhelmingly
represented in both the alcohol-related
injury and death statistics, about
72 per cent of the years of life lost
due to alcohol in New Zealand.35
A recent analysis of national hospital
admission data for 15 to 24 year-olds
showed the broad spread of alcohols
involvement in illness and injury.36
A total of 5,413 young people were
hospitalised with alcohol-related
admissions between 2002 and 2006.
Admissions were considered alcohol-
related if alcohol was listed in the
national database as being one of the
first 15 diagnoses, or one of the first
10 external causes of the admission.
This approach is likely to significantly
underestimate the total number of
admissions. This figure also does not
include patients that were only seen
in an emergency department.
Of the 5,413 admissions, 34.7 per cent
presented with injuries, 28 per cent with
mental health problems and 11 per cent
intoxication.37 Of the injury cases, about
20 per cent were as a result of self-
harm, 20 per cent as the result of an
assault, and the remaining 60 per cent
roughly equally divided between falls,
motor car accidents and glass injuries.
Admissions among young people living
in the most deprived areas were more
than three times more common than
admissions among those from the least
deprived areas. Admissions were twice
as likely to be males as females.
The impact of alcohol on our tertiary health
services, and in particular the extent to which
alcohol-related injuries divert resources away
from other health needs, was graphically
demonstrated in a study of patients treated
at Christchurch Hospitals specialist Oral
and Maxillofacial Surgery Service over an
11 year period. Of the 2,581 patients who
presented with facial fractures between
1996 and 2006, almost half of the injuries
(49 per cent) were alcohol-related. Males
accounted for 88 per cent of these, and
78 per cent of the alcohol-related fractures
were due to interpersonal violence.38
Surgeon Kai Lee, who was one of the
research authors, told the Law Commission
injuries sustained in alcohol-fuelled violence
most frequently involved fractures of the
lower jaw or cheek bones. Depending on the
severity of the facial fractures, surgery may
last anywhere from under an hour to three
or more hours and may involve wiring of the
jaw and the insertion of plates and screws.
Patients are typically off work for two weeks
and unable to take part in sport for six weeks.
Some suffer nerve damage and scarring,
and in more severe cases require cosmetic
or orthodontic work. These costs are
borne by the taxpayer via the Accident
Compensation Corporation (ACC).
Patients waiting for elective oral and
maxillofacial surgery were also affected
if the surgeons were unable to find
the theatre time required for the acute
alcohol injury cases. Dr Lee states:
You can imagine the disruption to
peoples lives when they are told their
long planned surgery has had to be
AcuTe injury is one oF our MosT
siGniFicAnT heAlTh issues in relATion
To Alcohol.
You can imagine the disruption to peoples lives when they are told their long
planned surgery has had to be cancelled in order to accommodate these acute
alcohol cases. Surgeon Kai Lee.