28
109. The membership of the Law Reform Committees was also drawn from private
practice, universities and the public service.
110. Like the LR Committee the Law Reform Committees reported to the
Government and Parliament through the Law Reform Division of the
Department of Justice. The Law Reform Division of the Department also
promoted a number of Bills itself, independently of the Law Reform Committee
structure.
111. The purpose of the LR Commission was to co-ordinate delegation of work to the
Law Reform Committees, to maintain a link between the Minister of Justice and
the Chairpersons of the Law Reform Committees, and to review the progress of
the Law Reform Committees at least once a year. But in practice the LR
Commission had little to do and was virtually inactive.21
112. The Law Reform Committees were nominally sub-committees of the LR
Commission but reported directly to the Minister. In practice the Minister
seldom, if ever, acted upon the reports without first consulting the LR
Commission.22
113. Like its predecessor, the LR Committee, membership of the LR Commission and
its sub-committees was part-time and unpaid. Initially the LR Commission met
about three times a year, each meeting lasting a full day. The workload of the
sub-committees was substantially heavier - in some cases committees met for
half a day each week.23 Much of the academic writing at this time notes the
considerable contribution of lawyers to law reform via the Law Reform
Committees, the substantial commitment of time required and their loss of
remuneration in doing this.24
114. In relation to the effectiveness of the LR Commission structure Turner J stated in
1969:25
Altogether I have found the Commission a well balanced body, expressive of all
shades of legal philosophy, perhaps leaning rather towards conservatism than
21
Above n1, 92.
22
Rt Hon Sir Alexander K Turner Changing the Law (1969) 3 NZULR 404, 409.
23
Above n22, 410.
24
See for example Wellington Seminar on Law Reform [1973] NZLJ 17; David B Collins
Law Reform: A New Procedure for New Zealand [1976] NZLJ 441.
25
Above n22, 409.